关于祖源分析，没有土家族数据吗

kumotan - 父N1b2a-F1525+、母C7a2

土家族和当地汉族无法区分。尤其是wg的纳西/彝和北汉区分不够好，我甚至觉得纳西/彝低于30%（在同时有北汉的情况下，而不是只有纳西/彝完全无北汉）都不能起到很好区分族群的作用。之前看过白族的纳西/彝是40%左右，希望看到清代后和汉族交往比较多的贵州彝族的数据来佐证我的猜测。

果断的ANK2基因

土家族不管从父系类型上看，还是姓氏结构，都跟周边汉族有很大的区别，那种所谓人造民族的说法，多数是不了解实际情况，人云亦云罢啦

傻傻的PDE4D基因

土家族与当地汉族区别不大。

傻傻的PDE4D基因

土家族的确不是人造民族，土家族分布于武陵山区，使用的是藏缅语族的语言（现在可能还有十几万的使用人口吧）。但是在上世纪80年代“民族恢复”的时候把许多周边的汉族也算进去了，才达到现在数百万的人口规模

果断的ANK2基因

楼主测过吗？上面那位说跟汉族区别不大的，有证据吗？

唏嘘的PER4基因

我是土家族的，但是这个测试出来没带一点土家族信息，很疑惑

果断的ANK2基因

微基因没有把土家族纳入比例模型，所以测不出，我也是土家族，用其他计算器看，跟周边汉族还是有区别的，另外问一下，你父系是什么类型？

果断的ANK2基因

用K47可以看出区别的，E11的彝族成分也比湖南汉高，跟北方人差不多

果断的ANK2基因

蒙古族、朝鲜族、苗瑶畲这些跟汉族通婚都有限制？所以可以作为标杆？

果断的ANK2基因

还种族隔离。。。。。苗族分布很广，国内就有6~7个省有大量的苗族聚集，又不止凤凰腊尔山那点苗族，除了凤凰附近的苗疆因为当时跟汉族矛盾比较尖锐(也只有一段时间)，其他地区的有过屁的种族隔离

kaji - 无

有个土家族远亲，嗯，藏缅+苗族比例比汉人高

冷冷的AGT基因

{"result":[{"race_desc":"\u4e2d\u534e\u6c11\u65cf","race_en":"chinese_nation","race_probality":"0.943001","area":[{"block":"chinese_nation","race_desc":"\u5357\u65b9\u6c49\u65cf","race_en":"han_southern","race_probality":"0.523003"},{"block":"chinese_nation","race_desc":"\u5317\u65b9\u6c49\u65cf","race_en":"han_northern","race_probality":"0.259585"},{"block":"chinese_nation","race_desc":"\u50a3\u65cf","race_en":"dai","race_probality":"0.070306"},{"block":"chinese_nation","race_desc":"\u85cf\u65cf","race_en":"tibetan","race_probality":"0.042760"},{"block":"chinese_nation","race_desc":"\u7572\u65cf","race_en":"she","race_probality":"0.021026"},{"block":"chinese_nation","race_desc":"\u82d7\u7476\u8bed\u65cf\u7fa4","race_en":"miao_yao","race_probality":"0.018960"},{"block":"chinese_nation","race_desc":"\u5176\u4ed6","race_en":"other","race_probality":"0.0076"}]},{"race_desc":"\u4e1c\u5357\u4e9a","race_en":"se_asian","race_probality":"0.037412","area":[{"block":"se_asian","race_desc":"\u67ec\u57d4\u5be8","race_en":"cambodian","race_probality":"0.019231"},{"block":"se_asian","race_desc":"\u5176\u4ed6","race_en":"other","race_probality":"0.0182"}]},{"race_desc":"\u7f8e\u6d32","race_en":"american","race_probality":"0.019044","area":[{"block":"american","race_desc":"\u56e0\u7ebd\u7279\u4eba","race_en":"eskimo","race_probality":"0.019024"}]},{"race_desc":"\u5176\u4ed6","race_en":"other","race_probality":"0.0006","area":[]}],"case_id":"ANCESTRY","prefix":null,"description":"\u7956\u6e90\u5206\u6790","color":null,"detail_url":"\/report2\/ancestry\/"}

我是土家与汉族、苗族的混血，看这结果…

WeGene_10502A18

湖北土家族

与内容相关的链接

13 个回复